Finished Werewolf XXVIII: Omega Alpha - Game Finished - Postgame Up!
- Thread starter bbninjas
- Start date
- Status
PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
Just because you formed a hypothesis and the first part turned out to be true does not automatically mean the second part is also true.
Where? I can't find it and I can't search using my name.
It is true and I was only explaining at Reinforce's request. I was not trying to imply that was the reason you voted for me.
Not hammering also lets scum weasel their way out of a lynch, which is exactly what Ice Espeon did last game. We did have time left in the day but it wasn't much and it was day one, so hammering really didn't put the town at that big of a disadvantage.
I was not on every single lynch wagon. The only person I voted on was TGK and that was because he simply asked if anyone challenged if he was Wally so I don't see how I was on a lynch wagon.
I did state that I wasn't totally sure on Luis being scum until after TGK and a few others near the end of the day make it more obvious. I simply said I wasn't sure and wasn't planning on voting until I was positive that I was nailing someone that was a scum. I had intentions of voting for Luis towards the end last round and didn't realize that time was up when I went to vote.
That's because I was trying to gain information on Luis that was possibly not on the flip when he got lynched, if he had another ability that was super important, I wanted to know about it so I could plan on what to do next.
So.. TT posted one post about the scum teams with nothing else on possible scums or simply giving his thoughts on SilverSilent. Last game he was also rarly posting but almost each post came with his thoughts about a possible scum.
SilverSilent's explanation about him targeting Luis is... weak imo and I think he should be lynched.
PMJ is keeping to defend himself and no longer tries to find scums like he did in D1.
Yeowie is inactive and I find it hard to believe it is because Camo isn't playing.
SilverSilent's explanation about him targeting Luis is... weak imo and I think he should be lynched.
PMJ is keeping to defend himself and no longer tries to find scums like he did in D1.
Yeowie is inactive and I find it hard to believe it is because Camo isn't playing.
This reads genuine to me.
I also think this is genuine, but I do want to point out that it's very rare for info to be withheld upon a flip, and if it is withheld it'll be made really obvious that it is. In fact, all standard roles will fail when targeting dead players.
No, but the fact that the first part of the hypothesis is true means that it's definitely likely that the second part is true. You would be a top contender for lynch today anyway, as you were yesterday and no new info has been brought up which doesn't hurt you more.
I said 'a bit of a case' for a reason. It's spread out over various posts, but there are just a couple reasons put here and there. Nothing too major.
lol you can't just say "it is true" and expect me to leave it. That's not why we think hammering is scummy here -- we think hammering is scummy because it gives us less time to discuss, which is very true.
It was pretty clear that the lynch was going to change at that point, so yeah, I'd say you did it for the inno cred instead. We didn't have any proper alternatives, let's be real.
Ah, seems like my post wasn't clear enough. I was talking about Celever.
I also didn't realise that this was about me. I do have to point out that the only reason why I was on all the lynches is because I was the one looking through posts and finding cases lol.
OK I'm trying to figure out things from looking back:
@SilverSilent - I don't understand, if you have vote weight of 2, isn't that mean that TGK should had 3 votes on him? or am I missing something?
@SilverSilent - I don't understand, if you have vote weight of 2, isn't that mean that TGK should had 3 votes on him? or am I missing something?
I think he was merely giving an example as opposed to claiming.
So.. SilverSilent was here but decided not to answer.. that can mean he is too busy atm or he really need to talk to his scum buddies to think of an answer.
(Or that I'm missing something.. I'm still kinda new).
(Or that I'm missing something.. I'm still kinda new).
I guess so.
@Celever some people take time to put their thoughts together...
Considering that there is a Blaziken out there too, I'd imagine the Swampert is Team Aqua and the Blaziken is Team Magma. For now, I classify simsands: Aqua and EM: Magma. If a Sceptile appears it'd probably belong to a more independent role, like Steven. Unless the three are belonging to a trio of rangers; which is believable, considering Keith, Kate and Kellyn.
On the thoughts of SilverSilent, I dunno really. I think the whole case is weak and doesn't need a lynch, tbh.
You seem to be confirming this, but are you actually already in the know about Swampert? Are you trying to drag it away from yourself?
Considering that there is a Blaziken out there too, I'd imagine the Swampert is Team Aqua and the Blaziken is Team Magma. For now, I classify simsands: Aqua and EM: Magma. If a Sceptile appears it'd probably belong to a more independent role, like Steven. Unless the three are belonging to a trio of rangers; which is believable, considering Keith, Kate and Kellyn.
Wait, what?!, it is scumtell? PMJ, you have lied to me! Why did you deny it is scumtell? Trying to get some cred for yourself and reassure me? Two birds with one stone, it seems.
On the thoughts of SilverSilent, I dunno really. I think the whole case is weak and doesn't need a lynch, tbh.
PMJ didn't look scummy to me on D1 but now he seems to switch from hunting scums to only post things about the game, what is scumtell and what is not, plus defending himself.
I still wait for others opinion on SilverSilent though because even if it is logical to target a dead scum while being town, you've said it yourself that it is quite rare.
Do you think it could be that he is with Team Magma and he takes the abilities from the first scum who's got lynched like IE last game?
Empoleon_Master asked a question and I was simply giving an example. But yeah, that's essentially what vote weight is.
All I will say is none of those theories are right
You haven't posted today yet. Where the hell did PMJ lie to you? You haven't asked him a question...
...in-thread. Literally if PMJ flips mafia this could quite feasibly be a slip. 3 mafia per team seems likely, but it's almost unreal for us to have found the whole of Team Magma in the first two days.
Fair point.
All I will say is none of those theories are right
You haven't posted today yet. Where the hell did PMJ lie to you? You haven't asked him a question...
...in-thread. Literally if PMJ flips mafia this could quite feasibly be a slip. 3 mafia per team seems likely, but it's almost unreal for us to have found the whole of Team Magma in the first two days.
Fair point.
I think he was talking about yesterday when he posted saying he doesn't want to hammer and PMJ said it is not scum tell to hammer but didn't quote Yeowie in his post or posted it right after Yeowie's post.
PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
I was not actually scum hunting during d1.
No it doesn't.
No one but you thinks so. The only other people who voted for me admitted it was a sham vote.
Your argument holds less weight because I previously said I would support any lynch that wasn't my own. Not gonna dispute having any alternatives because that's what I said was gonna happen, holy crap I was right, what are the odds of that.
It's like you didn't even read my post. It's not a scum tell. PB meta treats it a one for reasons Celever outlined but it's still flawed logic because town hammers all the time. (Like yesterday.)
@bbninjas @Camoclone if no one reaches majority by the day's end, what happens? No lynch or most votes dies?
No it doesn't.
No one but you thinks so. The only other people who voted for me admitted it was a sham vote.
Your argument holds less weight because I previously said I would support any lynch that wasn't my own. Not gonna dispute having any alternatives because that's what I said was gonna happen, holy crap I was right, what are the odds of that.
It's like you didn't even read my post. It's not a scum tell. PB meta treats it a one for reasons Celever outlined but it's still flawed logic because town hammers all the time. (Like yesterday.)
@bbninjas @Camoclone if no one reaches majority by the day's end, what happens? No lynch or most votes dies?
- Status