Collecting "How Much is This Card Worth?" / "Is This a Good Trade?"

Daelum

Climbing the stairs to the top
Member
There's been one that has sold on eBay recently, and it was listed at $750 but sold via Best Offer, so it is most likely somewhere close to that price. I messaged the seller asking for the final sale price - I'll update y'all when I hear back.


I'm gonna add the prices I think you should expect, based on eBay sales and personal reasoning.


Shining Gyarados 65/64 (1st edition; PSA 10) $200
Shining Magikarp 66/64 (1st edition; PSA 10) $175
Shining Celebi 106/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $250
Shining Charizard 107/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $500-$700
Shining Kabutops 108/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $200
Shining Mewtwo 109/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $200-$250
Shining Noctowl 110/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $200
Shining Raichu 111/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $225
Shining Steelix 112/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $125-$150
Shining Tyranitar 113/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $250-$300


Those are just quick, rough guesstimates.
 

DrunkSpinda

Awakening!
Member
I bought this lot:

Alph Lithograph One
Rocket's Persian EX
Arceus LV.100 AR2
Hippowdon Lv X
Shiny Entei Promo
Entei Secret Wonders
Frost Rotom
Darkrai Lv X Promo
Blissey ex Unseen Forces
Houndoom Prime
Honchkrow Lv X
Kyogre SL6 Call of Legends
Typhlosion Prime
Shaymin HGSS Unleashed Reverse
Surfing Pikachu Rising Rivals
Flying Pikachu Rising Rivals
Magmortar Supreme Victors Reverse
Jirachi Rising Rivals
Cleffa Call of Legends Reverse
Venusaur Secret Wonders
Entei Secret Wonders
Venusaur Supreme Victors
Floatzel GL Rising Rivals
Arcanine Rising Rivals
Arcanine Rising Rivals Reverse
2 froslass GL Rising Rivals
Froslass GL Rising Rivals Reverse
Rayquaza Legends Awakened Reverse foil
Mewtwo Majestic Dawn Reverse
Dusknoir Stormfront
Beedrill Rising Rivals
Beedrill Rising Rivals Reverse
2 Bronzong Mysterious Treasures
Mismagius GL Rising rivals
darkrai G rising rivals
darkrai G rising rivals reverse
darkrai great encounters
dakrai majestic dawn
Shiftry rising rivals
Shiftry PT2 1st Edition(japanese)
Vespiquen E4 Rising Rivals
Raichu GL Rising Rivals
Nidoking Rising rivals
vaporeon rising rivals
mr mime e4 rising rivals
Houndoom great encounters
2 gallade e4 rising rivals
2 bronzong rising rivals reverse
hippowdon rising rivals reverse
lucario GL rising rivals
bastiodon GL rising rivals
Delcatty Platinum
2 Toxicroak PT1 Japanese 1st edition

All of this for 25 euro, was it good, bad, meh?
 

MountainDrew

Wishes Mega Umbreon would exist
Member
Daelum said:
There's been one that has sold on eBay recently, and it was listed at $750 but sold via Best Offer, so it is most likely somewhere close to that price. I messaged the seller asking for the final sale price - I'll update y'all when I hear back.


I'm gonna add the prices I think you should expect, based on eBay sales and personal reasoning.


Shining Gyarados 65/64 (1st edition; PSA 10) $200
Shining Magikarp 66/64 (1st edition; PSA 10) $175
Shining Celebi 106/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $250
Shining Charizard 107/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $500-$700
Shining Kabutops 108/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $200
Shining Mewtwo 109/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $200-$250
Shining Noctowl 110/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $200
Shining Raichu 111/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $225
Shining Steelix 112/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $125-$150
Shining Tyranitar 113/105 (1st edition; PSA 10) $250-$300


Those are just quick, rough guesstimates.



Dang! I honestly didnt think they were that much. Is that what they sell for or just what people put them for?
 

PokePhD

PokéBeach Verified Seller
Member
Yea I have sold several PSA 10s at similar prices.

Another one I'd like to throw out there:
Wailord ex (1st edition; PSA 10)?

Thanks for your input as well guys.
 

SheNinja

Aspiring Trainer
Member
DrunkSpinda said:
Alph Lithograph One
Rocket's Persian EX
Arceus LV.100 AR2
Hippowdon Lv X
Shiny Entei Promo
Entei Secret Wonders
Frost Rotom
Darkrai Lv X Promo
Blissey ex Unseen Forces
Houndoom Prime
Honchkrow Lv X
Kyogre SL6 Call of Legends
Typhlosion Prime
Shaymin HGSS Unleashed Reverse
Surfing Pikachu Rising Rivals
Flying Pikachu Rising Rivals
Magmortar Supreme Victors Reverse
Jirachi Rising Rivals
Cleffa Call of Legends Reverse
Venusaur Secret Wonders
Entei Secret Wonders
Venusaur Supreme Victors
Floatzel GL Rising Rivals
Arcanine Rising Rivals
Arcanine Rising Rivals Reverse
2 froslass GL Rising Rivals
Froslass GL Rising Rivals Reverse
Rayquaza Legends Awakened Reverse foil
Mewtwo Majestic Dawn Reverse
Dusknoir Stormfront
Beedrill Rising Rivals
Beedrill Rising Rivals Reverse
2 Bronzong Mysterious Treasures
Mismagius GL Rising rivals
darkrai G rising rivals
darkrai G rising rivals reverse
darkrai great encounters
dakrai majestic dawn
Shiftry rising rivals
Shiftry PT2 1st Edition(japanese)
Vespiquen E4 Rising Rivals
Raichu GL Rising Rivals
Nidoking Rising rivals
vaporeon rising rivals
mr mime e4 rising rivals
Houndoom great encounters
2 gallade e4 rising rivals
2 bronzong rising rivals reverse
hippowdon rising rivals reverse
lucario GL rising rivals
bastiodon GL rising rivals
Delcatty Platinum
2 Toxicroak PT1 Japanese 1st edition

All of this for 25 euro, was it good, bad, meh?

Heck Yeah it was good. Maybe even great!

Soul said:
Does anyone know the exact value of the Tropical Wind/Tidal Wave STAFF Promos?

I'd say in Mint/NM about $85, because of the reprinted copy of it. Correct me if I'm wrong.
 

Daelum

Climbing the stairs to the top
Member
MountainDrew said:
Dang! I honestly didnt think they were that much. Is that what they sell for or just what people put them for?


Yeah, I don't mean to be rude or anything, but I advise not giving out prices unless you can back them up with actual sale prices. Don't want people running around with false information :p
 

FreePandas

Mother Father Pandaman
Member
Hey, a guy who stopped collecting sold/traded me:
  • Latias* (EX Deoxys 105)
  • Darkrai & Cresselia Legend (Triumphant 99, 100)
  • Suicune (HGSS21 Promo)
  • Reshiram & Zekrom (BW004, BW005 Promo)
  • Typhlosion Prime (HGSS09 Promo)
  • Espeon Prime (Undaunted 81)
  • Gengar Prime (Triumphant 94)
  • Houndoom Prime (Undaunted 82)
  • Blissey Prime (HGSS Base 106)
  • Machamp Prime (Triumphant 95)
  • Raichu Prime (Undaunted 83)
  • Kyogre (CoL 12)
  • Bagon (Arceus SH10)
for $30 and Spiral Force/Thunder Knuckle eeveelutions (Vaporeon, Umbreon, Eevee, Leafeon, Flareon, and Jolteon).

Guessing the trade was pretty good, but I didn't start collecting until Dragons Exalted, so not the best with prices and wanted to check! :)
 

1OneManCrew

Rogue Enthusiast
Member
Soul said:
The ''How much is a card worth?'' Topic!


Computer Search $15+
Crystal Wall $3
Crystal Edge $3
Gold Potion $5

Skyla FA $20+
Bianca FA $20
Cheren FA $15-
N FA $20+/-

Golden Pokémon Catcher $35+
Shiny Rocket Helmet $5+

Shiny Altaria $10
Shiny Terrakion $18
Shiny Rayquaza $30+
Shiny Krookodile $12
Shiny Zoroark $12
Shiny Hydreigon $12
Shiny Emboar $12
Shiny Serperior $12
Shiny Chandelure $12
Shiny Reuniclus $12
Shiny Gardevoir $12
Shiny Archeops $12
Shiny Golurk $12
(All Shinies +/- $2~)

Landorus EX $30
Landorus EX FA $40
Keldeo EX $25
Keldeo EX FA $35
Cresselia EX $8
Cresselia EX FA $10+
Celebi EX $6
Celebi EX FA $8
Black Kyurem EX $10-12
Black Kyurem EX FA $15+
White Kyurem EX $10
White Kyurem EX FA $12-15

Ho-oh EX $10
Ho-Oh EX FA $15
Mew EX $15
Mew EX FA $20
Terrakion EX $10
Terrakion EX $15
Registeel EX $8
Registeel EX $12
Rayquaza EX $12+
Rayquaza EX FA $20
Giratina EX $5
Giratina EX FA $8

Entei EX $6
Entei EX FA $8
Kyogre EX $8
Kyogre EX FA $10
Raikou EX $10+
Raikou EX FA $15+
Groudon EX $8
Groudon EX FA $10+
Darkrai EX $15
Darkrai EX FA $30+
Tornadus EX $15-20
Tornadus EX FA $20-25+

Shaymin EX $10
Shaymin EX FA $15
Reshiram EX $3
Reshiram EX FA $8
Kyurem EX $3
Kyurem EX FA $8
Zekrom EX $3
Zekrom EX FA $8
Mewtwo EX $15
Mewtwo EX FA $25-30+
Regigigas EX $8
Regigigas EX FA $10

Victini FA $6+
Virizion FA $5
Terrakion FA $15+
Cobalium FA $5

Tornadus FA $2
Thunderus FA $4

Zekrom FA $4
Reshiram FA $4

Secret Rare Meowth $5+
Secret Rare Pikachu $5+

Promo Mewtwo EX $8
Promo Darkrai EX $8
Hydreigon (Dark Trance) $8
Blastoise (Deluge) $7
Dragon Vaul Rayquaza $5

Tropical Beach $20+

Tropical Beach is $100+, isn't it? Also, whats the value on the PLF Kyurem?
 
Top