So this as a relevant posts/quote list with a comment/s on how it could point to being scummy (or not).
First up is Skyleaf.
(I started Day 2 because looking over the Day 1 posts would give me a headache.)
Finally, I can post again!
So if TGK was revealed town, and PP wanted to kill both TGK, (whomever Feenie is) and (whomever Maya is), then those two are probably town.
Does anybody have a cop ability?
Hey guys, remember this little 'slip' at the start of Day 2? Back then we dismissed it as a hasty mistake, but it might be worth a second look, because it looks like the one simsands first brought up wasn't the only 'slip' Skyleaf has done. Though that depends if you see this as a scumslip in particular.
After reading both the Celever and Luis cases, I feel inclined to put this as my vote, at least temporarily.
##VOTE: Luispipe8
A vote without elaboration. Recall that Camo was the one who created the Luis case; this could easily be a scum partner voting. Either way, Skyleaf has been simply agreeing with laid out cases and voting after them (more on that below and later).
Him saying this struck me as a bit odd for some reason... Why add in the underlined part if you hadn't found Phoenix yet? Maybe it's just me, but if I hadn't found Phoenix yet I wouldn't think to put that in.
Just a little thought.
This just might be minor, but there's an implication that Skyleaf sort of has an idea that TGK already found Phoenix?
I'm not exactly sure why... I can't put it into words... But Celever's actions today feel very strange. He seems more...energetic than usual. Both he and TGK, actually... He seems almost frantic to get TGK and simsands to stop tunneling him. The Celever I know is usually pretty calm, from what I've seen.
I'm not assuming TGK's town, but as of now I see no reason to assume he's scum either. (I realize Celever said this, too.) But of the two, Celever feels stranger today.
##FORNOW: Celever
Voting... And the reason is not based on any logic or evidence, plus there's an admitted echoing in there.
If there's no way to prove he's scum, what good would come of getting on his case like you did? I get it, don't trust him, he may be scum - but if he is scum, it seems like there's nothing we can do about it. We can't eliminate him without killing Maya, which you said isn't worth the risk... So what can we do? Just ignore him and say, "You're scum, I can't believe anything you say"?
If he's scum we can't do anything to get rid of him except killing Maya, whom you said not to attack. :V
The quote simsands first brought up, here's the full paragraph/context of it. The verb usage does stick out for some reason.
I feel a bit wary toward this comment. If PP were indie or scum, yay for him but nay for us. And if he were town, he'd just be another target for scum, who would know that this time they've got a townie in their claws.
And also, who was Dahlia if what PP says is true? >_>
A vague post, and some stating the obvious.
So I won't seem like I'm bandwagon-ing, I'll do this really quickly before I make my statement.
##UNVOTE: Celever
@Celever , I remain unsure who truly identified Phoenix first, but whether you were first or second,
what in the heavens could you possibly accomplish with this?
Literally all I could see this accomplishing is getting an instant target for scum, and maybe satisfying your emotion for a second. I know how good it can feel to deliver a sudden reveal, but I can't see how this would do anything but hurt town. If he's Phoenix, scum now know and will want to kill the high prosecutor. And from Simsands' recent posts, he seems to agree with being Phoenix.
Maybe you
did see TGK slip and reveal him. BUT THERE WOULD STILL BE A CHANCE SCUM WOULDN'T SEE WHAT YOU DID. What did you hope to accomplish by "outing Phoenix?"
All I can see happening is bringing Simsands into the spotlight and making him a particularly delectable treat for scummies.
Have I missed something,
@Celever ?
At the time of this quote, simsands already brought up the question of why she didn't want to seem bandwagoning and implied that that's suspicious. And recall that at first all she was voting for Celever for was 'being strange', and now there's this logical argument and reason. However, the time of this post someone else has already brought those questions up versus Celever, so this might be categorized as echoing.
In addition, lately it has seemed like you're mainly just trying to get votes off of you, and I'm having difficulty telling who you're trying to make people vote on, instead of you. Are you trying to make us vote TGK? What about this?
Similar to the one above.
I'm...not exactly sure how to put my thoughts on him into words, but I'll do my best. My mind works in images.
Imagine a stage with a huge spotlight ring lighting most of it. People are standing and wandering all over this stage. The more I study them in-game, the deeper red-colored they become on the stage. People are identified as strange (perhaps scummy) to me when spots of other colors flicker across them. More flickers appear when they've made weirder posts.
Right now, Celever is dark pink. Not red, because I don't know everything about how he plays. You and Simsands are very very close to white, because I get next to no read whatsoever on you two. However, Simsands has next to no "scum flickers" because he seems to be Phoenix.
However, not everyone is in the spotlight. King Xerneas is a good example. He stands at the edge of the light, mostly in but partly out. He's completely white, but he's had a couple small scum flickers. He seems to mostly avoid everyone's gazes but if you manage to spot him he will stay put, meeting your eyes firmly and neither seeming scared nor angry.
Does that make sense? If not, please ask questions.
A little poetic, but it does say that her voting on Celever was based on something kind of vague.
This feels like it might be a quick attempt to get votes off of him, but I have seen someone do the same thing and turn out town. (That was PP in Dimensional Shift.)
But all in all, the absolute confidence of this post makes it feel a bit more scummy than town.
This is after Celever has posted his case on KX, and votes/questions were piling up on him. If she's scum, then this might be considered subtle supporting.
Is there a way death by poison would show a false role upon flip?
The second suspicious quote, and I have to agree it is, because it was very out of the blue at the time of posting. The previous posts were about Celever and Jabber & TGK arguing and bbninjas listing the town and scum points of Celever and KX. Plus, this is a very oddly specific question about a death or game mechanic, that you just can't help but suspect that she does have an idea about the topic she asked. The last time something like this happened, it was Jabberwock in the Fire Emblem game, and he turned out scum.
While I do admit that the actions of GM Draclord are very strange, I feel he should be looked into tomorrow, as my instinct tells me to stick with KX.
Just in case:
##UNVOTE: whomever I voted for before
##VOTE: King Xerneas
I feel as though both of these are likely scum, but as I haven't looked into GM as much I will put/keep my vote on KX.
Votes KX with 'instinct' as reason, similar to the reason for votes she made on Day 2.
I actually kind of agree with this; to me it felt like the sudden interest in you came out of nowhere. I realize that the case on you was made back on page 48, but why suddenly bring it up now?
@scattered mind ?
A bit of echoing.
Well that's all up to end of Day 3... So, here are the conclusions/scummy points she might have done:
-Echoing
-Bandwagoning
-Reasoning out her votes with just 'instinct' and being vague
-Suspicious quotes on speculation about death/game mechanics that could hint that she has knowledge about it
Do you think it is enough for a case and enough to consider her highly likely scum? I personally believe so because of the quotes, but then the reason for suspecting those quotes is something a little meta (e.g. based on a similar act in a previous WW game) and a possible semantic/language issue, which I think is not solid enough to vote or lynch her immediately. But I think I'll be watching her posts more closely in case she makes more 'slips'.
Next I'm going to look over is grant's posts. There's fewer of them so it should be faster, though if I have a lot of analysis on it, it could take a while as well.