RE: What cool new Pokemon do you want to see in the 6th generation?
Metalizard said:
Fennex said:
- evos for rather immature and ignored Pokemon (Dunsparce, Qwilfish, Shuckle, Spinda, Luvdisc, Chatot, Farfetch'd, Delibird, Basculin)
...
Things I don't like to see include:
- an excessive amount of unnecessary weird-looking evolutions for old Pokemon (like Magnezone, Lickilicky, Tangrowth, Probopass and others in Gen 4)
I don't get how you say pokémon like Dunsparce, Qwilfish or Basculin should get evos while at the same time you consider the pokémon in bold "unnecessary weird-looking evolutions"... They may be weird (and there's nothing wrong with that either) but they were not unnecessary... Tangela, Lickitung and Nosepass are on the same level of the pokémon you mentioned... Even Magnezone... You think Magnezone is unnecessary but you think Shuckle should evolve? Shuckle has a really high BST, I don't see it evolving anytime soon (only if they make another Scyther/Scizor situation)...
The emphasis here is on unnecessary
combined with weird appearance. You're right that I might have included Tangela and Nosepass if they hadn't obtained evolutions yet.
It's just when I look at Tangrowth and Probopass, I think that, in retrospect, it would have been better not to add an evolution just for the sake of it. (without any innovative concept)
In contrast, Yanma or Sneasel were supplemented by interesting and useful evos. This also applies to the split evos. Magnezone, though useful in competitive gaming, is aesthetically a blunder and IMO unnecessary.
Concerning other evolutions in Gen4 (Lickylicky, Rhyperior, Electivire, Magmortar, Dusknoir), I think that there were other Pokemon (and still are) that needed an evo more urgently.
As for Shuckle: I listed Pokemon with the need of an evo just based on their immature appearance not on their BS. Gen 4 introduced a pre-evo for Sudowoodo (BS 410), but an evo for Tangela (BS 435) and not vice versa, that's why I guess BS is not the main argument for adding one of the two. A shuckle evo could have a slightly higher BS like Porygon2/Porygon-Z or just a redistribution of stats like Scyther/Scizor.
Also, I do not hope that all the Pokemon I mentioned will get evos/pre-evos in one Gen. It's rather a list of those that may need one or another for the future.
I'd like to see about 110-120 new Pokemon this Gen, including 16 Pokemon related to older ones (4 pre-evos, 8 evos, 4 split-evos), not more than 11 legendaries (regular trio, mascot trio, 2 event-only and 2-3 additional post-game legendaries) and the rest (80-90) arranged in new lines (2 additional split-evos, and 4-6 lines with unique type combinations).