yeah it would be held around the christmas new years time, like i said, everything in the first post was just giving you a general idea of how things would work out. As for the pannel of judges im not sure if how you stated is how we would really do it. What i was thinking is that during the last months of the year there could be a poll where everyone could see it with the names of the people who made a peice in their corresponding categories. then all the members of pokebeach get to pick the 3 or 4 nominees to be chosen for the reward. now that i rethink im not sure if the judges would make the FINAL decision the members may come in again in the final choice because sreiously, this is basicly all about what the majority of people on pokebeach think (wich would be all the members)