You have an interesting point.
I'mma just ##UNVOTE for now. Zone is definitely not the best lynch anymore, in my eyes at least.
I'm looking at Mariano, Jplap, TE, and NP to a lesser extent. If yall want explanations for any of those, just ask.
Finished Mafia LVI : Revolt at the Zoo -- GAME OVER!
- Thread starter bbninjas
- Start date
- Status
I'mma just ##UNVOTE for now. Zone is definitely not the best lynch anymore, in my eyes at least.
I'm looking at Mariano, Jplap, TE, and NP to a lesser extent. If yall want explanations for any of those, just ask.
What are the current reasons for suspecting Nick again?
Neither of those are reads dude. One is a vote to get reactions and the other is a question to see how Vi is thinking.
I townread Jplap because I'm feeling genuine frustration from him about being scumread. I've townread him for most of this time.
Have any interesting unique reads?
He's one of the people who have been sitting on the sidelines and are just bandwagoning and not making thoughts for themselves and just going with the flow of the thread rather than trying to catch scum.
There are few others like him out there who I'm keeping an eye on but he's most egregious in this respect.
hmm.. fair enough.
TE asked you to give reasoning and you ignored them. Also that DFL read is weird. Is he even playing? Did he make a post? How did you come up with him? Also also.. you are one of the first 5 posters (yes I am still on that theory).
##UNVOTE
##VOTE: Kiiruma
How does one tell that someone is particularly scummy? This is a skill I obviously need to have as I'm not really reading anyone as sum atm.
One is scummy for lots of possible reasons like:
- staying under the radar: Focusing on players that ere already discussed and talk about them once in a blue moon and then vanishing.
- Contradiction- says something then does something against that in a way that has no seemingly explanation
- Avoiding answering questions- commenting on other posts.
- Makes posts that has no real contribution - things that everyone already knows.
- Focused on roles and abilities and trying to gain information on them instead or more than person's alignment
- Reacting only to Zone (like Mariano, I am watching you btw).
- Doing something that is not like him in past games where he was town
- Agreeing too much with the general public. No original thought
And many more. Basically you can just look for other people's cases and see if you agree with their logic or not. If you agree just say so and if not write what bothers you with that case.
I'll bite.
I don't really see this as likely because of a point TE brought up previously.
I think that if NP was Jplap's scumbuddy, he would make sure that jplap doesn't pull something like this, allowing Jplap to be suspected and potentially preventing him from being suspected by association. I feel like what you're suspecting NP for is way too obvious for someone to make as a mistake or to hide their cover.
While I entirely agree with this I think Nick's situation in general is just a pain because he did this in the last game I played with him, where I was a new player linked to him and was seeking guidance from him, however he was inactive the entire game and I had to ask other people like bb for help. That combined with how bad I've seen his inactivity be in other forum games, I don't think it's a suspicious thing for him to do, just a bad thing for him to do.
With that being said though this is my last check through the thread before the day ends, so I'm most likely just going to be keeping my vote the same. I don't really think the current big suspects of the game are scum because I think the way they're acting is just related to their actual personality rather than just making scumtells, jplap is the biggest person I'm suspecting so I'm just keeping my vote on him for now.
##VOTE: Zone
So that I don't get penalized. Zone's gonna be lynched anyway.
So that I don't get penalized. Zone's gonna be lynched anyway.
D1 Vote Count #5
Zone Q11: 3 (L-6)| MegaPod_781 [#30],
Ninja Penguin: 2 | Zone Q11 [#29], Dusk Form Lycanroc [#36],
TeamAqua4Life: 1 |
GM Draclord: 1 | Kiiruma [#33]
Kiiruma: 1 | scattered mind [#224]
Mariano11887: 1 | Tigger [#143]
Professor_Jplap: 1 |
GekkisaiDaiNi: 0 |
Jadethepokemontrainer: 0 |
MegaPod_781: 0|
scattered mind: 0 |
TOTAL_EPICNESS: 0|
No vote: Blinkehyo, GekkisaiDaiNi, GM DracLord, Jadethepokemontrainer, TeamAqua4Life #HEYNICK, TOTAL_EPICNESS
Majority: 9 votes
Hours remaining: ~24 hrs
Past vote counts: [#1], [#2], [#3], [#4]
Note: This vote count does not show any decreased or increased vote weights, if any.
Note: If you do not vote by day end, you WILL be penalised. You do not want to be penalised.
@tigger and @Dusk Form Lycanroc need to make at least one more post to meet activity requirements.
I've been talking to Jade and am satisfied with their posting so far. However, Tigger and Dusk Form have both been absent for the last 24 - 48 hours.
Last edited:
Scattered definitely isn't pushing the easy lynch options here I think he's town.
Okay first this is like your tenth game and I'm annoyed that only now you're asking this. Scattered's list he gave is fine, but I think it misses the number 1 concept behind scumhunting: are they genuinely trying to catch and lynch scum, or are they trying to survive? Scattered listed some stuff that's a manifestation of this issue, but you can go a ton deeper into considering people's motives behind their posts, the intended effect of them, the perspective and angle they're going from, etc. and catch scum super well that way also (this is the source of a big picture mafia argument between if reading people on content or tone is more effective).
The thing is that he hasn't been inactive. To the contrary, he's posted over ten times so far this day phase. You might think it would be less because Nick has contributed none of his own thoughts in any of those posts, besides when I asked for more explanation after sheeping me.
I won’t argue with NP’s case on me as I’ve been more active this Day 1 than most and recent personal events have me a bit flustered right now (rip my dog). At this point I am just waiting for Tigger and DFL to get active so I can actually read everyone as a group without having to post some and then go wait for somebody else.
So it's less of being inactive and more just not contributing, that makes sense. With that reasoning I could see Nick possibly being scum, though I'm not convinced from that reason to move my suspicions off Jplap to target Nick instead.
You have 13 other players. You can read some of them.
Only Zone vs NP, I'm not sure whose better to keep but if I have to choose, I rather NP styas
##VOTE : Zone
This will be my last post.
##VOTE : Zone
This will be my last post.
Neither of you have ever expressed anti-zone sentiments and then y’all pull this out of nowhere? Blinkey didn’t even give his reasoning and Drac hasn’t once given any of his reads. these are both incredibly suspicious and now I’m really thinking y’all are a scum team trying to take an easy lynch as this is the literal definition of bandwagoning
- Status