My first scrach!

[Echosong]

Its is my first scrach it took awhile to make but i think it came out good.Please rate from 1-10.

Its a ninetales btw.

 

[Max Shade IV]

It's alright. A little more varience in the color and longer forelegs are needed. But I personally like how the head turned out. Considering it is your first, that's pretty darn good. 7/10

 

[kaze]

i actually really like this one!!!

 

[-SF-]

Pro +: Good shading style
GOod Detail

Con -: Bad outline
Not enough hue shift



Not bad for your first try though! Keep it up!

 

[Achmetha]

It is pretty bad, but I'm not trying to discourage you. Your outline needs refining. You should also have a lot more contrast. Your shading also lacks refinement and a lightsource. Perspective seems off as well. Finally, save as .png!