Okay I finally got a good amount of time on a computer.
Why are you ignoring all the posts about you? Here are just some of the posts you did not bother giving an answer to:
I'd like to point out that in the last two quotes in that post, which you can find linked to in the quote above, aren't really something you can defend against. They're more so points saying that LC's item is bad on scum, but aside from that, the votes don't really have an apparent reason aside from the item. However, those are still only a couple posts, and there are more directed at him. Cherrim, just because not all of them are questions doesn't mean you can't defend against them. Just read over them and share your opinion. Considering how inactive this game is rn we need all the opinions we can get.
This is unhelpful. Pressuring inactives, and telling them that you are voting them because you want to pressure them, is useless. The idea that you can do what the hosts themselves do every time they post warnings that these inactives are going to die or being replaced by the gigantic sublist we have in this game, and actually convince inactive players to become more active just because you told them "I am voting you, I have nothing on you and this is only for pressure" when we are less than 24 hours to the end of the day, and there is a clear lynch candidate, is unhelpful for the town at the very least. When you lynch someone over any scummy point you find- you don't earn better chance to hit the nail on scum, but you do earn responses about the point you made. You have something to work with and generate discussion that may lead to other reads on other players. Lynching random inactive doesn't do that. And if you say I'm wrong, explain to me when ever was there in the history of mafia, that a great discussion was created under an inactive case, that is not about the pros and cons of lynching inactives in general.
While I do agree with you in the sense that pressuring inactives doesn't really help, I feel that this post is a bit aggressive.
double o
#120 I disagree about the not coming up on anyone elses scumdar thing. Sometimes other people miss what you see, or you could see something that isn't there. Really depends on a lot of what is going on. So early into the game, I don't see that explanation as anything other than uneeded, but it isn't harmful in anyway, just something note worthy to me
My point with that was that at the time it read a bit to me like she was trying to see if a wagon would form, but seeing as no one else was voting, she took her vote off.
Thought that had to do with the item, but it must have been Tortuga :/ Voted for him because of the item he seemed to have. stupid reason to vote. Really though it was because of the bandwagon. Reason for bandwagon first time playing, getting excited, same stuff I said in previous post.
Admitting that he voted because of the item rather than trying to make some excuse is reading as townie for me.
How about a reads list?
NP - neutral - He's active, but the whole thing about keeper and PMs was a bit weird, and he seems a bit aggressive, though iirc he's played like this as both town and scum so idk.
Vracken - neutral - The pressuring inactives thing is a bit weird, but he is contributing a decent amount.
Simsands - leaning town - I always find it hard to get a good read on him, but that post about the ports helps so he's leaning town.
scattered - town - Considering that this game is really inactive, the fact that he is actively scumhunting reads to me as town.
Cherrim - leaning scum - the fact that he hasn't really responded to any of the posts directed at him is weird, so is him being iirc less active than his last game. However a part of me thinks that he's just a really confused townie atm which is why he isn't a total scum read.
Keeper - town - He's active, and his posts have a decent amount of contribution. Also he shared the info about Fiddler's Green which is helpful.
Lord - leaning town - seems pretty open to sharing opinions and I liked her response to my post about her a while back.
Cypher - leaning scum - His activity seemed to drop a bit after morda got lynched, and even then his posts don't really have a major amount of content.
Vom - leaning town - pretty active and contributing a decent amount.
Jade - leaning town - looks like an excited first time townie.
Drac - neutral - I can never get a good read on drac, and he just subbed in so not much I can really say here...
Blakers - leaning scum - For basically the same reason as Cypher.
I'm not really sure which port I should vote for, if we really can talk at night at Fiddler's Green then I think that'd be great, but the thing about it being odd is giving me second thoughts :/
