Popular Pokemon TCG Artist Accused of Tracing Fan Art for Upcoming Pocket Set

Ah ok, but I would say that some aspects of it are a bit different from the fan art
Long time professional artist here, and for "some aspects" to be "different" is common in tracing. Tracing is a good tool to learn things like anatomy or understand the form of something you're bad at drawing, and many artists will do it *as practice*, but some will try to use it in their formal works to bandage what they're not comfortable with.

You won't trace the whole thing you're tracing from in its most base form; you will make modifications (sometimes by lasso tool to cut parts and then re-pose the part you cut into a different position, or drawn by the artist themself where they feel confident in drawing), so it's harder to perceive as traced, or you may trace from multiple pieces (called "frankensteining"). Alternatively, the base sketch might be traced over, but the final artwork's lines are drawn to the sketch so it "seems" different enough due to differences in artist style. There's tons of ways to do so, but those ways will typically include some variance.

All this to say, a good artist knows how to do so effectively to minimize risk; think of it like how cheaters in a game are sometimes great players who know how to get away with it.
 
The bootleg figure thing has already been disproven. The pocket art is an exact trace of the original art. People have lined up both arts and it's basically an exact match. This means the artist DID trace the original art because there's simply no universe in which they line up so perfectly otherwise.
That sucks
 
I mean, the posing is the same but the shades of it are different so maybe it was just a coincidence that they share the same pose. There are also some aspects of the pocket card that make it different compared to the fan art
delusional levels of sweeping
 
To play devils advocate (not defending the tracing):

In a world where a lot of card artists have and will continue to use genetrative AI to make art that takes steals assets from a variety of artists and negatively impacts the environment, is tracing an image as bad compared to what others card artists have done using AI. Again, not defending them or trying to say what they did was right but we should atleast appreciate the colors and other aspects of the card a that could have been generated by AI.

I do hope they allow them to continue to make card art, as we all mess up sometimes and deserve to correct ourselves but hopeful TPCi uses this to possible amp up their inspection process of the card art to make sure everything is original
 
To play devils advocate (not defending the tracing):

In a world where a lot of card artists have and will continue to use genetrative AI to make art that takes steals assets from a variety of artists and negatively impacts the environment, is tracing an image as bad compared to what others card artists have done using AI. Again, not defending them or trying to say what they did was right but we should atleast appreciate the colors and other aspects of the card a that could have been generated by AI.

I do hope they allow them to continue to make card art, as we all mess up sometimes and deserve to correct ourselves but hopeful TPCi uses this to possible amp up their inspection process of the card art to make sure everything is original
really amazing display of how thoroughly ai has melted vulnerable peoples' brains, defending art theft this desperately is not "not defending" it just because you pinky promise that it isn't what you're doing.
 
really amazing display of how thoroughly ai has melted vulnerable peoples' brains, defending art theft this desperately is not "not defending" it just because you pinky promise that it isn't what you're doing.
I’m not saying it’s right or should be done, also- my comments before this were before it was actually confirmed that the artist came out with this info, so I did not want to falsely accuse until it was official confirmed
 
I’m not saying it’s right or should be done, also- my comments before this were before it was actually confirmed that the artist came out with this info, so I did not want to falsely accuse until it was official confirmed
the artist wouldn't need to confirm this to you if you weren't singlemindedly interested in making excuses (it was clear to anyone with functioning eyes), only to then shift to unprompted ai whining in an attempt to very transparently minimize what they admitted to having done. a classic "nuh uh they didn't do it but also if they did it isn't that bad" in real time.
 
the artist wouldn't need to confirm this to you if you weren't singlemindedly interested in making excuses (it was clear to anyone with functioning eyes), only to then shift to unprompted ai whining in an attempt to very transparently minimize what they admitted to having done. a classic "nuh uh they didn't do it but also if they did it isn't that bad" in real time.
Idk man, I like to make sure that it is 100% confirmed that they admitted it before saying that it is. I will admit, they are practically the same, but I will say that AI art levels worse than this- not saying this isn’t bad in anyway.

It’s kinda like if u got shot vs. getting stabbed. Ya, they are both bad, but you would rather get stabbed then shot
 
Idk man, I like to make sure that it is 100% confirmed that they admitted it before saying that it is. I will admit, they are practically the same, but I will say that AI art levels worse than this- not saying this isn’t bad in anyway.

It’s kinda like if u got shot vs. getting stabbed. Ya, they are both bad, but you would rather get stabbed then shot
To play devils advocate (not defending the stabbing):

In a world where a lot of criminals have and will continue to use firearms to commit murder, is stabbing a person as bad compared to what other criminals have done using guns? Again not defending them or trying to say what they did was right but we should atleast appreciate the knife skill and other aspects of the assault that could have been done by a bullet.

I do hope they allow them to avoid jail time, as we all mess up sometimes and deserve to correct ourselves but hopefully the police uses this to possible amp up their firearms screening process to make sure everybody is safe
 
To play devils advocate (not defending the stabbing):

In a world where a lot of criminals have and will continue to use firearms to commit murder, is stabbing a person as bad compared to what other criminals have done using guns? Again not defending them or trying to say what they did was right but we should atleast appreciate the knife skill and other aspects of the assault that could have been done by a bullet.

I do hope they allow them to avoid jail time, as we all mess up sometimes and deserve to correct ourselves but hopefully the police uses this to possible amp up their firearms screening process to make sure everybody is safe
U got me there lol. But I doubt stabbing someone is the same level as tracing something lmao
 
From what it seems, the artist didn’t purposefully go out to trace someone’s art but traced a reference material given to them by the official people behind it. So it was just a mistake
 
the artist wouldn't need to confirm this to you if you weren't singlemindedly interested in making excuses (it was clear to anyone with functioning eyes), only to then shift to unprompted ai whining in an attempt to very transparently minimize what they admitted to having done. a classic "nuh uh they didn't do it but also if they did it isn't that bad" in real time.
Hey hey hey, AI usage in art and tracing are both evil and awful and the people who do them professionally get sent to the level of hell where testicular torsion happens.
 
Back
Top