I mostly agree with this – most "scumslips" aren't really scumslips (and tbh they come more often from blundering town) – but I will say that IIOA is very, very scummy. ...although I found myself pretty darn guilty of this on D5, what with my huge walls with no conclusion. Bleh. Early game (D1) IIOA is pretty scummy, especially when the player tries to pass it off as analysis. When the player is more self-aware of it, then it's not as big a problem, but still.