Finished Mafia LVII: Big Brother Betrayal: Game Over! Postgame Part 1 Up!

Discussion in 'Forum Games' started by NinjaPenguin, Feb 25, 2019.

  1. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    directing us to a town loss yeah
     


  2. VioletValkyrie Tattered Queen~ ☆
    VioletValkyrie

    Chat Room Staff Member

    Fine, that's fair. But please find a better way of interacting with us to motivate us to do so instead of this?

    This... just makes you sound ridiculous.

    I don't think I've asked up to this point, so what specific reasons do you think I'm scum?
     
  3. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    The fact that the vote count proves that the last remaining mafia has intended to bus their way to this point this entire game
    and you've been involved DIRECTLY in two mafia deaths
     
  4. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    and i mean it might make me sound ridiculous
    but do you really feel like you're arguing with mafia right now?
     
  5. VioletValkyrie Tattered Queen~ ☆
    VioletValkyrie

    Chat Room Staff Member

    You got... anything else besides the ridiculous idea that I killed my theoretical scumbuddies this entire game..? I said it before and I'll say it again, there's literally no way that's what I'd do as scum.

    Short answer? More or less.
    I mean if I'm town and you're disagreeing with me and trying to get me killed...
     
  6. VioletValkyrie Tattered Queen~ ☆
    VioletValkyrie

    Chat Room Staff Member

    I seriously still don't understand how once I agreed with mirdo you seemingly pulled a gun on me and started shouting I was going to die. I think that's the biggest thing that's throwing me for a loop right now. That and how you did that, yet didn't include anything about it once you stated your reasoning for why you think I'm scum. To me it looks like you basically just tried to pick a target, picked me, and tried to make-shift things together to fail to form an argument about why I should be put to death for killing scum.
     
  7. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    Yes, your tone as the game has progressed hasn't sounded defeated as all. As the town members fall, if anything, you sound more encouraged like you're getting closer to the end.

    Explain to me this - as the last remaining mafia
    Why am i trying to pull teeth and make enemies before i die? And IF YOU ARE TOWN, Does me scumreading you always make me mafia or can it just make me wrong? What about my tone is making me come off as mafia to you?

    also i'm not trying to get anyone killed i'm just trying to win
    prove to me you are town with your logic and i'll no longer be trying to kill you, it's just that simple
     
  8. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    the point isn't to state reasoning
    if i'm about to die i need my messages to be remembered
    if i drone on and on about semantics people are going to forget about it after i flip which i can't have happen
    the messages need to be short and concise so they will be remembered once i'm gone
     
  9. VioletValkyrie Tattered Queen~ ☆
    VioletValkyrie

    Chat Room Staff Member

    I've been sounding more encouraged because I've been forced into a position where I have to lead the town core because no one else is doing it. No one else is speaking up. I was encouraged after killing Nyora. Because she's scum. And as town, killing scum accomplishes our wincon. Simple as that.

    Nah, you can be wrong and be town. Like I said, I'm not convinced you're scum. I don't know how many times I'm gonna say this.

    This.

    The point is to state reasoning when I asked you what your reasoning is. That's like... the reason I asked.

    You honestly can't say you haven't been trying to get people killed when you've been so aggressive in trying to kill Blink, and now trying to kill me. Y'know, I think I've been trying to prove something but I don't think what I'm saying is really being listened to.~
    [​IMG]
    God, why do I not post gifs on the forums more often? So much fun.
     
  10. VioletValkyrie Tattered Queen~ ☆
    VioletValkyrie

    Chat Room Staff Member

    Sorry, I meant completely convinced. Like I said you're my best shot, and with how strange you've been after I asked your reasoning for suspecting me, that's not getting any better for you. I'm getting there.
     
  11. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    [​IMG]

    ~~yes you're right gifs are great~~
     
  12. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    I gave my reasoning after you asked, it wasn't necessary for the initial posts though

    Except there is someone else doing it, I'm here speaking up. You're trying to remove the only other voice actually trying to solve the game. If you're town you have to realize this, yeah?

    Trying to get lynched is what mafia is all about. If i hadn't pushed on blink i wouldn't be townreading blink now
    that's how you end up solving is TvT scenarios
     
  13. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    Explain to me how i'm your best shot when I'm the only other person actually trying to solve and discussing the game at the moment
     
  14. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    essentially you pushing for my nomination, in my mind, boils down to
    "You were arguing with blink and blink is the HoH. He's going to be more than eager to nominate Marl"

    I don't see any actual reads behind your scumread of me. Give me some.

    Yes i was arguing with blink before he became HoH.
    Yes if i had won HoH he'd have gone up with Jade today.
    Yes, his actions as HoH have lead me to believe he's probably town in the end.

    Where does any of this start to show i'm mafia and how? I can't follow your logic so help me follow it.
     
  15. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    how am i acting strange?
    I've explained my line of thinking clearly
    if you have any questions, just ask and i can elaborate more
     
  16. VioletValkyrie Tattered Queen~ ☆
    VioletValkyrie

    Chat Room Staff Member

    So you gave your reasoning... just not the reasoning that I wanted you to give?

    I've been trying to assess what's going on as a whole, not to mention I was pulling all of the shots when we were doing the live competition, which you were nowhere to be seen for. You've basically just been aggressively tunneling specific people. Sure, that's a good point and I now realize that, but I'd rather have a voice I'm confident is part of towncore, rather than one I'm mixed at best about.

    Because inactivity is not the only contributor to being scum. Inactive town seems incredibly common in this game, and I don't want to kill off town I know are inactive just to try and whittle down the possibilities of who could be scum. I feel more confident targeting those I suspect of being scum, rather than those inactive. Worst-case scenario, that's a mislynch on someone I'm not confident about, which makes it a lot easier for town to lose.

    Sounds exactly right.

    Your eagerness to target and tunnel people, your only contributions to town seems to have been wanting to win HoH so that you could kill of Blink, and sure you weren't led to believe he was town at that point, all you've seemed to be doing is just pointing a target at someone and wanting them dead.
    I said earlier this week that mirdo was my second pick and it was only because he's neutral in my eyes. First pick was either you or Blink with how most of the week was basically just a big argument between you two, and if I'm townreading Blink it makes a lot more sense for you to be scum.

    Can I get any explanation on this, then? What's up with this?
     
  17. VioletValkyrie Tattered Queen~ ☆
    VioletValkyrie

    Chat Room Staff Member

    Elaborating on this. You don't seem to be listening to anyone else, simply just wanting to kill someone off. It really doesn't make it seem like you're acting in town's best interest, and instead your best interest. If you are town, we can stop arguing about this and actually try to agree on people we suspect and try to think about who to kill off rather than you wanting to shoot to kill and hoping it works. You really don't make it seem like you're trying to win for town, but rather for yourself, because you think you're right in who you're suspecting.
     
  18. VioletValkyrie Tattered Queen~ ☆
    VioletValkyrie

    Chat Room Staff Member

    I'm not trying to specifically kill you, like you're trying to kill me. I'm trying to kill whoever I suspect most to be mafia, and I'm perfectly willing to let that suspicion float to whoever picks it up. You just really aren't letting that happen for me right now.
     
  19. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    bleh i'm wrong
     
  20. Marluxion Aspiring Trainer
    Marluxion

    Member

    these last few questions have been incredibly towny and i can't in good faith try to argue that i'm arguing with mafia here
     

Viewing Now: 0 Members + 0 Guests

There are no registered members viewing this forum. Why not register here and start a discussion?

Moderated By

Vracken

Share This Page