Finished PokeBeach Mafia 50: Fray at the Beach - Game Over - Claim Your Prizes and Vote!
- Thread starter bbninjas
- Start date
- Status
So...could we lynch Sim? Or is that old news now?
I meant, like I would be able to tell if the ability was scummish or not. Ninja Penguin said it would be a good idea to do it because I could get a good read on a player...
I am still for it.
You seem so sure about that name guess killer theory? It appears as a fact to you. To my knowledge the only thing that pointed to that possibility was Blakers being killed with Latios written on his body. Also Jplap's reveal did not result in his dead and Mimikyu is the only Pokémon that fits with his role flavour. Did I miss something?
I never said it, and I don't think it.
No, I don't want to send to the trash all the discussion you had about Sim. I'm perfectly fine with Sim's lynch too, I think if one of them (Sim or TE) flips scum, the other one will be seen as townier, and I pointed out that, to me, TE is a better lynch because I see more scummy things on him.
What I do want is to lynch either TE or Sim because it will give us info about the other. If people agree that Sim's lynch is better, ok, my vote will be there. For now, I keep it on TE until I see again a clear trend to Sim.
What? As far as I could read on your claim, you can switch your ability with another player, not the alignment. BB would never tell you the alignment of the player you swapped with.
The name guess killer was an assumption yes but I’m sticking with it
I’m not 100% sure anymore due to Jplap surviving but BB did say claiming would be dangerous and it fits with Blakers’ death
If you look at my flowchart Sim is a better lynch in all situations
He flips scum I’m town we lynch a scum
He flips town you lynch me and you’re down a town and a scum
You lynch me
I flip town you still don’t know who Sim is
I flip scum You know Sim is town
In only one of those situations where you lynch me you know who Sim is and in the other you’re lost and down a town
In both of the situations where Sim is lynched you not only know who he is but who I am as well
He flips scum I’m town we lynch a scum
He flips town you lynch me and you’re down a town and a scum
You lynch me
I flip town you still don’t know who Sim is
I flip scum You know Sim is town
In only one of those situations where you lynch me you know who Sim is and in the other you’re lost and down a town
In both of the situations where Sim is lynched you not only know who he is but who I am as well
^ This post from Drac is a good enough answer for me.
And I might as well add that pretty reckless, since it'd be a huge target on them to act that way.
Is this really the reason you thought there were 2 swappers? It's just funny flavor. Even my role has it, it shouldn't be indicative of something else than Kabutops' cold-blood killing mania :v
If anything it's a 1 time use Ability. Otherwise scum would kill every player who roleclaims by now; both jplap and TLP should have died if that was true.
##UNVOTE:
Everything is starting to become a bit clearer now. However, I've just two more questions for you @Acetrainer_samwise
1. Does your ability swap just abilities, or Pokemon themselves? If it's the former, you are right - here are definitely 2 Pokemon that can switch things around (as shown in the Day 4 announcements)
2. Did you switch abilities with @scattered_mind during night 2, or night 3?
Everything is starting to become a bit clearer now. However, I've just two more questions for you @Acetrainer_samwise
1. Does your ability swap just abilities, or Pokemon themselves? If it's the former, you are right - here are definitely 2 Pokemon that can switch things around (as shown in the Day 4 announcements)
2. Did you switch abilities with @scattered_mind during night 2, or night 3?
I apologize for asking so many questions about roles and actions, and I understand if you want to keep things secretive.
However, the answer to question #2 is very VERY VERY important here. @Acetrainer_Samwise
However, the answer to question #2 is very VERY VERY important here. @Acetrainer_Samwise
You know I can also answer these, right?
1. Only abilities. I even quoted it for you a few pages ago.
2. Night 2. Night 3 I swapped with sim.
So...who are we lynching today?
Thanks, but I need an answer from just @Acetrainer_Samwise . I want to hear specifically what he has to say on it.
I don’t understand why Sim is no longer a viable option or how Samwise is better
Samwise isn't better, I just started a vote on him to add pressure so he could stop messing around with us and explain himself.
Actually, I have to take this statement back. The Day 4 announcement said that "Someone swaps their soul with another Pokemon". However, it is very possible that the names of the Pokemon are just being treated as aliases of the players instead of a representation of what "Pokemon Body" they have.
We don't need another page of text on this.
I'll be back later after 8:00 PM to cast my final vote.
I did actually. You mean at present, you are the one with the Di Nuovo ability and he now has the swapper one? I thought it was the other way round.
In that case it's another reason to keep Samwise off the lynch for today.
It just hit me. We must lynch sim. If he is scum he can swap Di Nuevo and lynch 2 townies.
Oh.. that is not good. I don't think we can take that risk guys.
Oh.. that is not good. I don't think we can take that risk guys.
*kill 2 townies
- Status