The most condemning evidence is that sim hinted that he'll look into AP during D2, and then on D3 he said he has reasons to believe AP is telling the truth, and that he can't reveal why (obviously because of some kind of an ability he used last night). The problem is that any ability sim used on AP had to tell him otherwise since AP was scum by N2. So there is no logical explanation for that defense. There is, however, a very logical explanation about his ability to know AP is his scumbuddy, since it is possible that he used an ability during N2 to find out. So sim is like 99% scum to me. :
Page 26 sim posts this and it is implied that he wants to say something on AP but keeps it for later for some reason
"Yesterday, most of the focus went on Dusk Form Lycanroc, Lord Goomy, Anime Psyclone and pikachuuuu101 (and Tyler).
Both DFL and Goomy, I'm reading as genuine newbie town. They don't seem scummy to me.
pika got some attention later on during the day for jumping on the Tyler wagon without any ..
There is also one other player who I'm reading as scum, who I want to look into. Today is probably not good, but I'll try to get the time to read back tomorrow."