Hot take but I think Brilliant Stars might be THE most influential set (competitively) we've ever had in the history of the game. Only time will tell but It has a TON of both strong new cards and reprints.
Yes that's true, it is reusable with scoop, but marshadow is stronger because you can preemptively have it on your bench and it doesnt take up a bench spot, which is very important for a lot of decks. I question how many decks will actually be viable with 4 scoop up net post rotation (due to...
Gourgeist and swap cup are unplayable, but pumpkaboo is a slightly worse resetting hole marshadow that will definitely see play after rotation. Having an easily searchable out to removing path to the peak (which gets way stronger after swell rotates) will be important to have.
Amazing set! I can't wait to start playing with these cards. I think this is the best sword/shield set we have got so far (both in terms of collecting AND competitive).