Bad Gaming Journalism Debunked, ‘BREAK Starter Pack’ to Mostly Contain Reprints of Recent Cards

Break Starter PackBack in October, I first reported about a new “XY: BREAK Starter Deck” that is to be released in Japan in February for Pokemon’s 20th anniversary. The deck’s product sheet highlighted that its design is meant to evoke the nostalgia of Japan’s original “Pokemon TCG: Starter Deck” from 1996, sharing the same artwork.

While the original product obviously contained cards from the original Base Set, no such promise was made for 2016’s deck. In fact, the title of the product retained the current era’s title, “XY: BREAK,” which was the biggest clue that the deck’s nostalgia was only skin-deep and that it would most likely contain modern cards.

Last week, Pokemon officially revealed the deck on their website for the first time. We of course posted a news story here within minutes of its reveal and our large translation team of Pokemon TCG fans concluded that the product listing only stated that the deck would be “revisiting” Base Set. Like in October, nothing was stated about the deck’s contents other than it will contain 60 random cards. For all we knew, “revisiting” meant what the product sheet highlighted months ago – that the design is revisiting Base Set. The point is, nothing was stated about the actual cards.

Cut to yesterday. A large gaming website mistranslated and misinterpreted the news from the official Japanese website, posting that the official Pokemon website had stated Base Set was to be re-released. Okay, fine, they misinterpreted the news – I mean, who wouldn’t think Base Set cards were being reprinted if they’re not a Pokemon TCG fan who follows this stuff? It’s an honest mistake, I’ll give them that.

But then as I continued reading… a couple of details that were never stated anywhere showed up in their article. The only way these statements could have been made is if the authors went out of their way to make them up. The official Pokemon website they cited as their source never stated anything along the lines of what these journalists were claiming.

Polygon (original source of bad reporting) :

Title: Original Pokémon trading card game set getting an anniversary re-release
Author: Allegra Frank
Source: Official Japanese Pokemon Card website

The very first set of Pokémon trading cards is getting a re-release, just in time for the series’ 20th anniversary. On Feb. 27, Japanese Pokémon fans will be able to purchase the original base set in its first reprinting in years, according to the official trading card game’s Japanese site… Featured on the cards are designs identical to their 20-year-old counterparts.

And then of course the news spread everywhere, with no one checking the original source, asking questions, or doing any kind of basic research. Most of them just parroted each other and thus the misinformation spread like a California wildfire. I started to have flashbacks to the time Nintendo sent me a cease and desist over my coverage of Pokemon Black & White and a bunch of gaming websites completely misrepresented the situation to their readers, parroting false statements and interpretations other websites had made, and failing to do real research like reporters should. It makes me wonder what else these gaming websites misreport, or even the media in general.

Keep in mind that the following websites are reporting about a completely random Pokemon product that only has a nostalgic design and using said news to state or imply that Base Set is being reprinted. Even if they were only announcing this product, there are much larger 20th anniversary TCG products these websites never posted, so they’re giving weight to something that’s not important only because the aforementioned website made a big deal out of it (proven further by the fact the news was over a week old and they all just happened to post it within the same few hours). Even on PokeBeach, a fansite dedicated to Pokemon, this product was so unworthy it was posted within other articles. And then of course many of these gaming websites copied the made-up “facts” the first site reported, like good journalists:

Wired:

Title: Classic Pokémon trading cards are making a comeback
Author: Matt Kamen

Prepare for playground wars to erupt once more — the original Pokémon trading cards are getting reissued, as part of the 20th anniversary of the franchise… The 60-card base set will reproduce the 1996 editions perfectly, with the original character art and designs intact.

Anime News Network:

Title: Relive the Early Days of the Pokemon Card Game with Original Starter Pack
Author: Eric Stimson

Next year, the Pokemon trading card game reaches its 20th anniversary — the cards first went on sale in Japan in October 1996. To help bring back some memories, the original starter pack will be re-released on February 27 for 1,300 yen ($10.80).

Siliconera:

Title: Original Pokémon Starter Packs To Be Re-Released For Their 20th Anniversary
Author: Chris Priestman

It has been announced that the original Pokémon trading card game starter pack will be re-released in Japan on February 27th 2016.

Kotaku:

Author: Brian Ashcraft

Next year is Pokémon’s 20th anniversary. To mark the event, the card game’s first starter pack is getting a re-release.

GoNintendo:

Author: rawmeatcowboy

– first set of Pokémon trading cards is getting a re-release
designs are identical to their 20-year-old counterparts

NintendoLife:

Title: First Edition Pokémon Trading Cards Are Getting A Reprint For The 20th Birthday Of The Franchise
Author: Damien McFerran

That means that next year is the 20th anniversary of the birth of the franchise, and to celebrate this milestone fans will be able to purchase the very first base set of Pokémon cards – in Japan, at least. The set will include 60 cards, a manual and coin. The cards will be identical to the original print run, and launch in Japan on February 27th, 2016.

MyNintendoNews:

Title: First Edition Pokémon Trading Cards Will Be Getting A Reprint For Pokémon’s 20th Anniversary
Author: natalielevig

It looks as though the first edition Pokémon trading cards are going to get a reprint in 2016 for the 20th Birthday of the Pokémon franchise, based on information on the official Japanese Pokémon TCG website.

Nerdist:

Title: Original Pokémon Trading Cards Rereleased to Celebrate Series’ 20th Anniversary
Author: Jessica Maria MacFarlane

… And then there’s this little dozy–the first rerelease of the original base set of Pokémon trading cards, complete with identical designs and artwork! On February 27, 2016, Japan will get to catch 60 original base set cards, a special-edition player’s manual, and a collector’s coin for a to-be-determined price. Oh, we can already feel the import wars online stirring!

And then the “news” became so popular it ended up on Facebook:

Facebook Pokemon TCG Base Set Fake News

And then the few fans who tried posting the correct answer were downvoted into oblivion on Reddit, a site which prides itself on users promoting the best comments / news and culling the “worst.” In this case, the “news” had over 1,600 upvotes while the actual correct answer had -1. It was subsequently hidden from the discussion:

Reddit

I and other Pokemon TCG fans in-the-know immediately jumped to action and e-mailed, Tweeted, Facebooked, and messaged the authors of many of the above news stories. I even posted an article yesterday stating what we do know, acknowledging that while it’s possible we may get Base Set reprints, nothing has been confirmed by an official source (or at least the official Pokemon source everyone was citing).

However, none of the authors responded even though some of them were active on social media after we reached out to them multiple times. We’re not sure if this is because they didn’t see our messages, didn’t care, or didn’t want to own up to their mistakes. People sometimes have difficulty doing the latter, so I imagine we won’t see many retractions. That’s why you should always go to people who do know what they’re talking about when it comes to news like this. If we at PokeBeach are ever wrong about something (and of course in 13 years of covering Pokemon news on this site I have been wrong before), we’ll go out of our way to let you know so you’re not misinformed.

So now we have some actual news! We have just discovered (a little late) that Amazon Japan has actually posted a full description of the product in question along with an image. Thanks goes to Ryah R., our head translator, for the translation:

XY BREAK Starter DeckThe first random deck in the Pokemon card game XY series!

With a few exceptions, the cards comprising this product are reprints from the Pokemon Card Game: XY and XY: BREAK series. (They have the same backs as the Pokemon Card Game: XY / XY: BREAK  series so they can be played together.)

The set includes 1 random deck (60 cards), 32 damage counters, 2 markers, 1 coin, and an instruction book. The cards are random. Due to the nature of a constructed deck, it will contain some duplicate cards.

So there you have it: the majority of the deck will contain reprints of cards from the past few years (so certainly not 60 Base Set cards from 1996). Therefore, what all of the above news websites reported or implied is incorrect (as we stated yesterday). To think news so false became so popular and wound up on several large websites and even Facebook’s right menu… it makes you wonder how often real news organizations misreport, lie, and spread incorrect news about real issues that we gobble up and accept without thinking twice about.

The blurb does however imply “a few” cards outside of the last two eras will be reprinted. This could mean any card from the Black and White era’s last set, Plasma Blast, all the way back to Base Set. But there’s an additional clue in the blurb: it goes out of its way to say all the cards in the deck will have modern card backs. This seems to be implying that the “few” cards they’re reprinting had the old Japanese card backs originally. This would narrow down the selection to cards from Base Set to around Neo Destiny. You can go further and assume that the reprinted cards will all be Base Set cards because of the packaging, but even then, this is still unconfirmed and it would only be a “few.”

We still don’t know what America’s Generations booster packs will contain, but it could be whatever those “few” reprinted cards are. If the selection of reprinted cards in the new Starter Deck does in fact span several years of sets, it would make sense why our booster packs are named “Generations” (if in fact they do contain cards from this BREAK Starter Deck). Or – an even more random theory – what if they’re cards America never got from Japan, such as the Vending Machine cards? The point is, we don’t know anything at this point.

As usual, you can stay tuned to PokeBeach for the latest Pokemon news! Maybe now since the fake news turned out to be so popular Japan will take the hint and reprint all of Base Set in the future. Maybe for the 25th anniversary? Hopefully I’ll be in the film industry by then. :p

Update: GoNintendo reached out to us and has now corrected their story.

Update: Anime News Network reached out to us and has clarified the confusion (on their forum).


PokéBeach's news commenting system is completely integrated with our forums! , you can reply to this story's forum thread directly on this page with all of the forum's functionality!

  1. awesomeMSG Just a guy who wants to master Greninja BREAK
    awesomeMSG

    Member

    I love that chansy coin. Finally a coin other than the three Kalos starters and Pikachu. I'm hoping these "few" cards we will be able to play with competitively. Hopefully these cards will actually be useful like maybe a fighting type/water type so we may be able to use Maxie / Archie. That could make 2016 one of the most remembered years of pokemon with multiple generations being used in decks. (other than unlimited.)
     
  2. Crimzonlogic I'm Batwoman.
    Crimzonlogic

    Member

    Since there's a chansey coin, maybe we get a new version of the original chansey in this.

    I'm really curious how these decks will be "random". Like, maybe a set number of energy, set number of trainers and set number of pokemon evolution sets/ex/breaks matching the energy type? A truly random bunch of cards would probably make an awful deck...
     
  3. Blui mentos - the freshmaker
    Blui

    Member

    Absolutely legendary, you've outdone yourself Jon.

    This product seems sweet, wish the US got starter packs like this as they can be pretty good.
     
  4. Empoleon_master I can stop watching Anime any time I don't want to
    Empoleon_master

    Member

    First of all whoever says there is no journalism in pokemon news should get slapped with a 50 page thick copy of this article printed out, secondly oh, look, WPM posted a list of websites I will now NEVER GO TO because fact checking is for losers, and thirdly #inb4 a news article states that pokemon is giving away a coupon for a free, gold plated puppy + metal coin and instruction manual with every purchase of a....$10 theme deck.
     
    The-Kaiser likes this.
  5. Qwachansey Aspiring Trainer
    Qwachansey

    Member

    Chansey is my favorite Pokemon... I would love to see a new Chansey to match the coin!
     
  6. Shiny Xard 'Cuz why not.
    Shiny Xard

    Member

    I'm honestly a bit happy that the rumor won't come to be. The cards aren't even close to playbale in any format. People are just nostalgia-blind.
     
  7. TheUltimateAbsol Truth or Ideals? It's all Black and White to me
    TheUltimateAbsol

    Member

    And no news source talked about exact reprints of coins? Come on, They are the bigger deal here.
     
    Empoleon_master likes this.
  8. EEVILMURRAY Aspiring Trainer
    EEVILMURRAY

    Member

    Oh well, these things sadly do happen, whether it was simply a mix of misreading and wishful nostalgia or simply an attempt to grab views. Especially if the site is more popular than yours these things can spread very far very fast.

    At least they added the é in Pokémon* (as well as the majority of the links you took text from). Might be something you want to look at in your future articles.


    *Same goes for PokéBeach, even though the other article didn't mention your site.
     
  9. Pinecone A Pinecone on the Beach
    Pinecone

    Member

    The trainers would be too playable and too OP. As for Pokemon, you're right, with the exception of Blastoise. Despite being inferior to Blastoise BCR, it would still be viable in Standard with Archie.
     
  10. The-Kaiser Starfleet Captain and Pokemon Trainer
    The-Kaiser

    Member

    Shishigami likes this.
  11. Zielo Caught 'em all.
    Zielo

    Member

    Thanks for clearing this up. Its been circulating around social media for the last couple of days, and the second I saw it I clicked my Pokebeach bookmark to see the latest news. I saw nothing about it, and my usual assumption is "If its not on Pokebeach, its probably not true". And sure enough, its not confirmed lol.

    Although it WOULD be pretty cool for them to do something with the base set cards for an anniversary. Maybe update them to newer times, but keep all the original art. That or clean up the art to where they are all polished versions of the old cards, just like the reprinted Charmander like, Pikachu, Scyther, etc.
     
  12. RiverShock Aspiring Trainer
    RiverShock

    Member

    I doubt any will have the original back. It seems like a few will be either new cards (which I'd imagine is likely the case) or pre-XY reprints (though there is ZERO hint of this beyond the nostalgic packaging).

    I wish I could just state a few Base-era cards they could reprint (if they do). But Electabuzz is the only "safe" call. It was iconic in its era, it would still be somewhat useful (if we had an Electivire that didn't suck), and doesn't really have any details that would need to be changed. (Even now, not all our Lightnings have a Metal resistance.) I'd love to say Hitmonchan, but since BW, we've had several cards that were heavily based on (and better than) Hitmonchan, such as Sawk BW and BREAKthrough Hawlucha. I guess Venusaur/Charizard/Blastoise could work, though Charizard is pretty bad. I also don't like its Fighting resistance...
     
  13. Athena Sprightly Bride
    Athena

    Advanced Member Member

    I'm kind of disappointed that most of the deck will be recent reprints, but I can't help but get a good chuckle at all of the false rumours spreading around like wildfire.
     
  14. Pinecone A Pinecone on the Beach
    Pinecone

    Member

    The new Pokemon TCG starter pack sure garnered a lot of attention.

    If they knew what this really was, no one would have posted the story. They were wrong, but their error made it newsworthy.
     
  15. Requiemsvoid Aspiring Trainer
    Requiemsvoid

    Member

    Thanks for the heads up, I forwarded a link to this page on KotakuInAction as well as sent a PM to the mods of the Pokemon subreddit.
     
  16. WrightJustice Aspiring Trainer
    WrightJustice

    Member

    Sadly still not seeing any corrections even with the news reveal, even /r/pokemon or /r/PKMNTCG don't seem to have the new news up.
     
  17. OVERGRO Pokemon is lyfe.
    OVERGRO

    Member

    Hats off to Pokebeach and WPM on this one!

    As someone who is active in sociopolitical causes I can tell you the "real" news is not always what it's cracked up to be either.

    Very well done here.
     
  18. Clear Carousel of Agony
    Clear

    Member

    Can I just make another jaded point here?
    This is the result of people's innate ability to move on from the insipid poison that is known as nostalgia. They did it because it was "trending", and (most) people want a feel good nostalgia story cause nostalgia is comforting.
     
  19. poke4trade Raising Ash
    poke4trade

    Member

    Great Research Pokebeach. I think the common thread in breaking news for the 2000's is to first break it than investigate it. In the old days, it was more in the reverse. Now a days credibility for news sources are very seldom held accountability for a sloppy job. I think this a very good example of keeping on target with pokebeach's message as a credible new source for pokemon.

    I don't know when it happened, but at some point we just sort of accepted the Windows version of life. Release it, than fix it. It is sort of the new norm now in all ways of life. ---> If Aristotle was around, he would have a field day with our new line of thinking.

    Great Job!
     
    Camoclone and OVERGRO like this.
  20. Saarebas Aspiring Trainer
    Saarebas

    Member

    I had shared the Polygon article on fb to discuss with friends, but my first thought was "Pokebeach hasn't said anything tho..."

    Well, we should be finding out more about the Generations packs soon, right? The first Mythical Pokemon Box comes out in February, which means we'll probably see them at Target in mid-January
     
    OVERGRO likes this.